Windows Develop Bookmark and Share   
 index > Windows Forms General > Windows forms or ASP.net
 

Windows forms or ASP.net

Hi, this is not a spesific technical question but a very general problem. We have two kind of programs we develop for the government:
One for external users to report data, throught internet pages, to the government. Then we use ASP.net.
But for internal users, the employees in the organisation, the users also use forms to save data in a database.
Some of us (developers) are convinced that we will use much less resources by using windows forms
instead of ASP.net for these applications. There is very little use and need of SOA (service oriented arcitecture) in the organisation.
Do anyone have any opinion about this? The data from the employees are used for different kinds of reports, on web.
I hope anyone can help me.
Best regards
ClaraCharlie  Tuesday, October 06, 2009 11:08 AM

Why not creating just one website only for internal and external users, and then define Authentication and authorization on it, so external users cant access internal users pages (Role based security), this is much more better instead on developing two separate application and maintaining it is also easier.

Yazeed Hamdan  Tuesday, October 06, 2009 11:18 AM
Sure WF apps will use less resources, web browsers are fat.  But does that really matter?  You can't buy a computer that can't run a web browser.  ASP.NET apps are popular because the solve the deployment problem, always an issue with a large distributed app.  WF apps are popular because they solve the reliability problem and are more responsive.  In any decent project, the decision would have been made at a very early stage in the design process.  You'd better check that.

Hans Passant.
nobugz  Tuesday, October 06, 2009 12:43 PM
External users are also more used to a browser then a custom application, internal ones could always get education for it. I think its a matter of how complex the application itself is.
VB.NET to C# http://www.developerfusion.com/tools/convert/vb-to-csharp/
Se3ker385  Tuesday, October 06, 2009 1:51 PM

You can use google to search for other answers

Custom Search

More Threads

• How do I get the current pixel's color from anywhere on the user's screen? .. By VB.NET
• Cross-thread calls to controls
• DoubleClick event effect on all controls
• Ordering of categories in propertygrid
• Writing a WinForm pgm for right click in Windows Explorer
• Performing other task while for-loop is underway....
• Refreshing PropertyGrid
• Can MonthCalendar Title Area be changed?
• Static Library in VS2005
• ImageList handles